Scientists at the U.S. Department
of Energy's Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory have been able to confirm
the production of the superheavy element 114, ten years after a group in Russia,
at the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research in Dubna, first claimed to have
made it. The search for 114 has long been a key part of the quest for nuclear
science's hoped-for Island of Stability.
Heino Nitsche, head of the Heavy Element Nuclear and Radiochemistry Group in
Berkeley Lab's Nuclear Science Division (NSD) and a professor of chemistry
at the University of California at Berkeley, and Ken Gregorich, a senior staff
scientist in NSD, led the team that independently confirmed the production of
the new element, which was first published by the Dubna Gas Filled Recoil Separator
Using an instrument called the Berkeley Gas-filled Separator (BGS) at Berkeley
Lab's 88-Inch Cyclotron, the researchers were able to confirm the creation
of two individual nuclei of element 114, each a separate isotope having 114
protons but different numbers of neutrons, and each decaying by a separate pathway.
“By verifying the production of element 114, we have removed any doubts
about the validity of the Dubna group's claims,” says Nitsche. “This
proves that the most interesting superheavy elements can in fact be made in
Verification of element 114 is reported in Physical Review Letters in an article
available online to subscribers at http://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevLett.103.132502.
In addition to Nitsche and Gregorich, the Berkeley Lab team included Liv Stavestra,
now at the Institute of Energy Technology in Kjeller, Norway; Berkeley Lab postdoctoral
fellow Jan Dvorák; and UC graduate students Mitch Andre Garcia, Irena
Dragojevic, and Paul Ellison, with laboratory support from UC Berkeley postdoctoral
fellow Zuzana Dvoráková.
The realm of the superheavy
Elements heavier than uranium, element 92 – the atomic number refers to
the number of protons in the nucleus – are radioactive and decay in a
time shorter than the age of Earth; thus they are not found in nature (although
traces of transient neptunium and plutonium can sometimes be found in uranium
ore). Elements up to 111 and the recently confirmed 112 have been made artificially
– those with lower atomic numbers in nuclear reactors and nuclear explosions,
the higher ones in accelerators – and typically decay very rapidly, within
a few seconds or fractions of a second.
Beginning in the late 1950s, scientists including Gertrude Scharff-Goldhaber
at Brookhaven and theorist Wladyslaw Swiatecki, who had recently moved to Berkeley
and is a retired member of Berkeley Lab's NSD, calculated that superheavy
elements with certain combinations of protons and neutrons arranged in shells
in the nucleus would be relatively stable, eventually reaching an “Island
of Stability” where their lifetimes could be measured in minutes or days
– or even, some optimists think, in millions of years. Early models suggested
that an element with 114 protons and 184 neutrons might be such a stable element.
Longtime Berkeley Lab nuclear chemist Glenn Seaborg, then Chairman of the Atomic
Energy Commission, encouraged searches for superheavy elements with the necessary
“magic numbers” of nucleons.
“People have been dreaming of superheavy elements since the 1960s,”
says Gregorich. “But it's unusual for important results like the
Dubna group's claim to have produced 114 to go unconfirmed for so long.
Scientists were beginning to wonder if superheavy elements were real.”
To create a superheavy nucleus requires shooting one kind of atom at a target
made of another kind; the total protons in both projectile and target nuclei
must at least equal that of the quarry. Confirming the Dubna results meant aiming
a beam of 48Ca ions – calcium whose nuclei have 20 protons and 28 neutrons
– at a target containing 242Pu, the plutonium isotope with 94 protons
and 148 neutrons. The 88-Inch Cyclotron's versatile Advanced Electron
Cyclotron Resonance ion source readily created a beam of highly charged calcium
ions, atoms lacking 11 electrons, which the 88-Inch Cyclotron then accelerated
to the desired energy.
Four plutonium oxide target segments were mounted on a wheel 9.5 centimeters
(about 4 inches) in diameter, which spun 12 to 14 times a second to dissipate
heat under the bombardment of the cyclotron beam.
“Plutonium is notoriously difficult to manage,” says Nitsche, “and
every group makes their targets differently, but long experience has given us
at Berkeley a thorough understanding of the process.” (Experience is especially
long at Berkeley Lab and UC Berkeley – not least because Glenn Seaborg
discovered plutonium here early in 1941.)
When projectile and target nuclei interact in the target, many different kinds
of nuclear reaction products fly out the back. Because nuclei of superheavy
elements are rare and short-lived, both the Dubna group and the Berkeley group
use gas-filled separators, in which dilute gas and tuned magnetic fields sweep
the copious debris of beam-target collisions out of the way, ideally leaving
only compound nuclei with the desired mass to reach the detector. The Berkeley
Gas-filled Separator had to be modified for radioactive containment before radioactive
targets could be used.
In sum, says Gregorich, “The high beam intensities from the 88-Inch Cyclotron,
together with the efficient background suppression of the BGS, allow us to look
for nuclear reaction products with very small cross-sections – that is,
very low probabilities of being produced. In the case of element 114, that turned
out to be just two nuclei in eight days of running the experiment almost continuously.”
Click here to read the full press