From biological effects and predictive models to life cycle assessment and industrial decision tools, researchers are testing how safety and sustainability can shape nanomaterials before they reach the market.

Paper: Safe and sustainable by design (SSbD) for nanotechnology: scientific foundations, global policy perspectives, and industrial practice. Image Credit: Bushko Oleksandr
A recent review published in the journal Nano Convergence examines how the Safe and Sustainable by Design (SSbD) approach can guide the development of safer, more sustainable nanomaterials.
The authors connect advances in nano safety science, computational modeling, life cycle assessment, global regulatory policies, and industrial applications. The review highlights decision-support systems and digital tools that help translate scientific evidence into practical design choices.
Embedding Safety and Sustainability into Nanomaterial Design
Nanomaterials possess distinctive optical, electronic, mechanical, and chemical properties that make them valuable for applications in electronics, medicine, energy, coatings, and environmental technologies.
These same properties can influence how nanomaterials interact with biological systems and the environment. Factors such as particle size, shape, surface chemistry, and dissolution behavior can affect their toxicity, environmental persistence, and potential exposure pathways.
Conventional approaches often evaluate material safety only after development, making subsequent modifications expensive and delaying commercialization.
Safe and Sustainable by Design (SSbD) offers a preventive approach by integrating safety, sustainability, and functionality into the early stages of material development. It encourages researchers to identify potential hazards and environmental impacts before they become difficult to address.
The authors trace SSbD's development through scientific research and international policy initiatives.
The European Commission introduced its SSbD approach in 2022 and revised it in 2025 after testing and feedback, providing a structured method for evaluating chemicals and materials. International initiatives, including those led by the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), further promote harmonized testing strategies and nano safety guidance.
The authors describe SSbD as extending beyond toxicity assessment to cover the entire material life cycle, from raw-material sourcing and manufacturing to use and end-of-life management. This broader perspective helps researchers balance material performance with safety, resource efficiency, and environmental protection. It also covers economic and social factors, including market viability and occupational health.
Connecting Nanotoxicology with Predictive Modeling
Understanding how nanomaterials interact with biological systems is important for identifying potential hazards and developing safer alternatives. The review highlights mechanistic toxicology, which examines the biological pathways through which materials may cause adverse effects. Instead of simply determining whether a material is toxic, researchers investigate how exposure alters cellular processes and molecular responses.
Advanced analytical techniques, such as transcriptomics, can identify changes in gene expression associated with cellular stress, inflammation, and other biological effects.
These insights provide mechanistic evidence for understanding how the physicochemical properties of nanomaterials influence biological responses. The paper also notes that transcriptomic data alone cannot capture protein function, cellular signaling, or post-translational regulation.
The authors also discuss new approach methodologies (NAMs), including cell-based assays and computational techniques, as alternatives to conventional animal testing. These methods can improve testing efficiency and reduce reliance on animal experiments. Their reliability depends on appropriate experimental design, validation, and high-quality data.
Machine learning and predictive modeling offer further opportunities to identify relationships between nanomaterial properties and biological outcomes. Using reliable experimental datasets, these approaches can help prioritize materials for safety testing and guide modifications to potentially hazardous properties.
Physiologically based kinetic (PBK) models provide another important tool by simulating how nanomaterials move through biological systems and distribute across organs. Recent advances account for physiological processes such as particle uptake by immune cells called macrophages. Their reliability still depends on experimental data and model parameters that can be difficult to measure.
Together, these approaches can strengthen early hazard assessment and enable more informed decisions when designing safer nanomaterials.
Integrating Life Cycle Assessment and Digital Decision-Support Tools
Predictive safety assessment forms only one part of the SSbD approach. SSbD also requires evaluating environmental impacts throughout a material's life cycle.
Life cycle assessment (LCA) examines the environmental burdens associated with raw-material extraction, manufacturing, transportation, product use, and disposal. This broader assessment can reveal impacts that might otherwise go unnoticed when researchers focus only on a material's performance during use.
Prospective LCA is valuable during early development because it estimates potential environmental impacts before manufacturing reaches industrial scale. These predictions involve uncertainties, but they can help identify opportunities to reduce energy consumption, emissions, and material waste.
Digital decision-support systems further strengthen SSbD by integrating safety information, exposure assessments, sustainability indicators, and predictive models. These platforms allow researchers to compare candidate materials and assess trade-offs between functional performance, human health, and environmental impacts.
The review highlights the HARMLESS project's decision-support system, developed by TNO, designed to assess complex multicomponent nanomaterials and high-aspect-ratio structures with substantially different dimensions. Its system combines hazard, exposure, and sustainability information within an iterative design process.
These applications show how integrated assessment can guide material development while maintaining functional requirements. Such tools have been demonstrated in industrial applications, while routine adoption across industry remains constrained.
Other initiatives, including the ASINA Expert System and the PARC SSbD toolbox, support life-cycle assessment, model integration, and structured decision-making.
The authors also discuss FAIR data principles, which promote findable, accessible, interoperable, and reusable data. Inconsistent datasets, difficulty connecting different databases and tools, and variations in assessment methods remain barriers to the wider adoption of these tools.
Global Policy and Industrial Implementation
Successful implementation of SSbD requires collaboration among researchers, industry, regulators, and policymakers.
The authors examine how different regions are developing strategies for nanosafety, sustainable chemistry, and advanced-material governance.
The European Union has the most operationally mature SSbD approach. The United States relies more on sustainable chemistry, computational toxicology, high-throughput screening, and existing chemicals regulation, while countries across Asia and Latin America vary in their nanosafety capacity and participation in international harmonization.
International cooperation is important because nanomaterials often move through global supply chains. Differences in testing procedures, reporting requirements, and sustainability indicators can make it difficult to compare materials across markets.
The OECD Working Party on Manufactured Nanomaterials supports international collaboration on testing and risk assessment, while other collaborative networks connect scientific and policy communities.
Industrial demonstration projects also help translate SSbD principles into practice. The DIAGONAL project, for example, redesigned silver nanowires for flexible electronics by producing thinner wires and recycling acetone, which can reduce immune-cell toxicity and the environmental footprint while retaining technological relevance.
Decision-support systems can help companies compare alternative materials, identify potential hazards, and evaluate environmental trade-offs before committing to large-scale production.
Toward Responsible and Sustainable Nanotechnology
The authors describe Safe and Sustainable by Design (SSbD) as an integrated approach for advancing responsible nanotechnology development. By bringing together mechanistic toxicology, predictive modeling, life cycle assessment, and industrial decision-support systems, the approach enables researchers to identify potential risks earlier and make better-informed material-design decisions.
They argue for incorporating safety and sustainability into the earliest stages of innovation and revisiting them as materials move through scale-up, commercialization, and end-of-life management. This shift could reduce costly redesign, improve resource efficiency, and support the development of nanomaterials with lower risks to human health and the environment.
Further progress will depend on stronger international harmonization, reliable data infrastructures, and wider access to validated assessment tools. Research into exposure pathways, long-term biological effects, environmental persistence, and end-of-life behavior will also be needed for improving safety predictions.
Overall, SSbD offers a pathway to align advances in materials science with human health, environmental protection, and industrial performance. Its wider adoption could help translate nanotechnology innovations into commercially viable products, but the paper notes that safety, environmental performance, cost, manufacturability, and functionality often involve trade-offs.
Disclaimer: The views expressed here are those of the author expressed in their private capacity and do not necessarily represent the views of AZoM.com Limited T/A AZoNetwork the owner and operator of this website. This disclaimer forms part of the Terms and conditions of use of this website.